March 22, 2006

Cleanliness is Godliness

First it was the turn of foreigners visiting Rajasthan to be educated about culturally inappropriate behaviour. Now the government of the northern Indian state has banned street habits often considered typically Indian. Graffiti and spitting and urinating in public have been outlawed across the state - although critics of the new law say more urinals should be built first.

Read more here.

My 2c (2 anna? 2 paisa? 2 Rupee?) worth:
Like other Gandhi-isms, truisms and aphorisms like 'Cleanliness is Godliness' have become meaningless cliches in today's India - mere words that people may bandy about in middle school but as a country, India is a dirty sloppy messy country. I agree that it can be a big challenge to 'teach' cleanliness to 1 billion Indians now.. but the filth is disgusting and uncomprehensible to Westerners visiting India. Like my Westerner boss said to me during a recent visit to India, 'Poverty doesn't mean they cannot put trash in trash bins - it is no excuse for being sloppy'... Thank God he didn't see that people do more than throw trash on the roads..know of a place near my grandparents' place in Mumbai where they have built 20 public loos.. but the kids (even adults maybe!) from the zopadpatti nearby all defecate on the roads despite the facilities made available..

So..in that context, it is a good initiative taken by the government of Rajastan, which sees its fare share of Western tourists. We should aim to be cleaner for our own good..not for tourists only.. but if tourism is the means to the end, so be it. However, I do fervently hope they can implement these rules... the best of plans of men and mice go awry and especially in India - because having these rules has no meaning unless there is some measure of accountability with regard to its implementation. Ofcourse, what does one do...start arresting people for littering? One surely does not need a police state! Maybe fining is an option for this is a minor infraction - not a murder or rape or even burglary? But then how does one ensure the perpetrators do not get away with paying a small bribe! How does one enforce this over millions of people... How does one then make sure people, educated and uneducated, rich and poor, follow this new rule... all of India is not quite Bihar..but still ..

Questions ...Questions... No answers... any interesting comments from readers here on how to make sure this can be implemented successfully...or even the broader question of how to we get India to be a cleaner nicer easier place for all of us.. Indians & tourists.

March 20, 2006

American Theocracy - Clear and Present Danger


Kevin Phillips, who as a young political strategist for the Republican Party, wrote in his 1969 book, The Emerging Republican Majority, that a stronger Republican Party would restore stability and order to a society experiencing disorienting and at times violent change.

No longer does he see Republican government as a source of stability and order. Instead, he presents a nightmarish vision of ideological extremism, catastrophic fiscal irresponsibility, rampant greed and dangerous shortsightedness. (His final chapter is entitled "The Erring Republican Majority.") In an era of best-selling jeremiads on both sides of the political divide, "American Theocracy" may be the most alarming analysis of where we are and where we may be going to have appeared in many years. It is not without polemic, but unlike many of the more glib and strident political commentaries of recent years, it is extensively researched and for the most part frighteningly persuasive.
 Although Phillips is scathingly critical of what he considers the dangerous policies of the Bush administration, he does not spend much time examining the ideas and behavior of the president and his advisers. Instead, he identifies three broad and related trends -- none of them new to the Bush years but all of them, he believes, exacerbated by this administration's policies -- that together threaten the future of the United States and the world. One is the role of oil in defining and, as Phillips sees it, distorting American foreign and domestic policy. The second is the ominous intrusion of radical Christianity into politics and government. And the third is the astonishing levels of debt -- current and prospective -- that both the government and the American people have been heedlessly accumulating. If there is a single, if implicit, theme running through the three linked essays that form this book, it is the failure of leaders to look beyond their own and the country's immediate ambitions and desires so as to plan prudently for a darkening future. ... He identifies three broad and related trends - none of them new to the Bush years but all of them, he believes, exacerbated by this administration's policies - that together threaten the future of the United States and the world. One is the role of oil in defining and, as Phillips sees it, distorting American foreign and domestic policy. The second is the ominous intrusion of radical Christianity into politics and government. And the third is the astonishing levels of debt- current and prospective - that both the government and the American people have been heedlessly accumulating. If there is a single, if implicit, theme running through the three linked essays that form this book, it is the failure of leaders to look beyond their own and the country's immediate ambitions and desires so as to plan prudently for a darkening future. 
The American press in the first days of the Iraq war reported extensively on the Pentagon's failure to post American troops in front of the National Museum in Baghdad, which, as a result, was looted of many of its great archaeological treasures. Less widely reported, but to Phillips far more meaningful, was the immediate posting of troops around the Iraqi Oil Ministry, which held the maps and charts that were the key to effective oil production. Phillips fully supports an explanation of the Iraq war that the Bush administration dismisses as conspiracy theory - that its principal purpose was to secure vast oil reserves that would enable the United States to control production and to lower prices. ('Think of Iraq as a military base with a very large oil reserve underneath,' an oil analyst said a couple of years ago. 'You can't ask for better than that.') Terrorism, weapons of mass destruction, tyranny, democracy and other public rationales were, Phillips says, simply ruses to disguise the real motivation for the invasion.
Read the full review at the link above. 

___

March 18, 2006

Book Review - House on the Edge of Tears

The same wind that comes from the sea has run down the same streets for forty years. The rain that used to drench the buildings crossed a field of ruins. At the two extremities of this field: a house where my father conducted a reign of terror and a grave where he found a place not meant for him. He was buried there by chance. War had scrambled the country’s geography: the dead were given up to the closest cemetery. …

… I exhume two of my dead and one living-dead: my brother who concentrated within himself all of his father’s ambitions and fury; I want to question them, open their mouths sealed in silence, to rout out by force the cause of those rages, as brutal and brief as resin-fires.

In a northern village, the tomb of a Maronite saint has been sweating blood for a century. My father’s grave oozes threats from its stony pores. My mother’s, modest and moss-covered, seeps tears.
My mother had only tears to defend her son. “God, let him be dead!” I would repeat until I was near fainting when my father was late coming home. I dreamed about being an orphan. Only his death would stop my mother’s tears, my brother’s cries of terror, and we three girls from trembling.

…So begins Venus Khoury-Ghata’s book,

A House at the Edge of Tears – published by Greywolf Press, 2005. After reading the first four pages, I was left feeling as if my very being had been churned, tossed, and spit out – not so much horrified by the brutality but disturbed and at the same time in awe of the immense effect mere words, conjoined into haunting sentences, had effected – bringing home images of a brutality and a grief that one couldn’t imagine, let alone empathize with.

Joyce Carol Oates wrote in her introduction to
The Best American Essays of the Century – ‘My belief is that art should not be comforting. For comfort, we have mass entertainment and one another. Art should provoke, disturb, arouse our emotions, expand our sympathies in directions we may not anticipate and may not even wish.’

By that measure, Venus Khoury-Ghata has written a veritable piece of art. Most novels, in my opinion, lose a lot in translation but if that is the case here, the talent of Khoury-Ghata can only then amaze one even more. Marilyn Hacker, herself a
poet and author of some repute, has brought us English readers a genuinely amazing read – so much so, I am tempted to go and immediately read Khoury-Ghata’s award winning book of poems, She Says, also translated by Hacker.

Without giving away too much of the story here or having to reproduce the entire four pages or the entire book, for that matter, suffice it is to say that the book takes us along on a relentless, brutal, and hauntingly poignant journey, without ever stooping to self-pity or self-indulgent sensationalism.

The author, a Lebanese poet and novelist, resident in France since 1973, narrates the story of her childhood in Beirut forty years ago – throwing ‘sentences on the page in great shovelfuls, with a noise of falling earth,’ digging into her shame like a grave’ – and takes us on a unsettling journey of her family’s angst, set against the backdrop of the interminable descent of Lebanese society into the chaos of war.

Other than
Without, a book of poems by Donald Hall, which I had read in one sitting deep into the night some years ago, and which had me bawling, commiserating with the loss felt by the poet over the loss of his wife, the poet, Jane Kenyon, I cannot remember any book that I have read - and there have been many over the years - which has evoked such a powerful emotional response from me. The story of this book, while sad and difficult, is not something which readers may never have encountered elsewhere. The grief and injustices suffered by the victims of war, the Holocaust, and other similar singular and not-so-uncommon travesties sometimes have a tendency to numb the spirit and have, in the past, prompted me to stay away from the mundane common fare of umpteen novels, fictional and memoirs, written each year about the tragedies that befall families and how they either fight through it or succumb to it. However, this is not one of those books… the reasons that make this book special and different is that the story was not what moved me but it was the words, the sentences, and the powerful images and their symbolism that conveyed…

Only in reading the Afterward at the end of the book, which the author signs off as herself and not as the narrator of the novel, did I realize that the power and potency of the words comes through a real familiar experience of the author. While the artistic liberties taken by the author in narrating the story of her brother are unclear, (the book not being indicated anywhere as being a memoir), clearly the novel is a journey of catharsis (’to each his own tomb: mine is in these pages’), guilt, fear, grief, shame (‘shame nailed me to the ground’, and finally, redemption (with the novel ending with ‘You (the brother) are the only survivor’).

--
Personal Note: At 110 pages, the novel is a short read but for all the reasons outlined above, can be a moving and difficult one. In fact, I found it very difficult to go past the first four pages the first couple of times. Interjected by the mundane routine of life and work, I moved to some ‘lighter’ reading, but came back to this book after a two-week hiatus on a flight from Boston to Cleveland. But re-reading the first few pages, I once again struggled to continue –not because the language is difficult, which has happened to me before with David Mitchell’s
Cloud Atlas and to a certain extent with Ian McEwan’s Amsterdam), but because the words affronted me with their brutal honesty - like the pomegranate tree in the courtyard of the narrator’s childhood home, ‘spattering the landing with bloody juice when its fruit burst open in the sun’. I stopped but restarted again at page 75 the next time and succeeded in reading the last 30 pages – and found that after that I was able to somehow making the necessary emotional leap to start again at the beginning. Reading the end prematurely may have taken away some of the ‘suspense’ from the reading but the writing is what kept me hooked, not the story and so I finished reading the entire book in one sitting (being stuck on a plane for 2 hours helped!) – starting again at the beginning and re-reading the last 30 pages again for a final complete reading of the book.

March 6, 2006

Oscars 2006

List of all the award nominees, with winners

'Crash' walks away with the top prize at the Oscars - Nice comprehensive article, as always..from the NYT (via IHT)


Personal comments coming later...time permitting!

March 5, 2006

Downfall - Last Days of Hitler

Last weekend I saw Downfall, the German movie about the last days of Hitler which got ravereviews Oscar time last year..

Undoubtedly a heavy movie..esp. at the end but a great must-watch movie! Not to give away much (I recommend you see it, though be ready to get into a heavy depressing mood at the end when the Nazis accept the inevitable, with the Russians closing in on them in central Berlin, in a very disturbing end... but heck...they deserved every bit of it. Movies like Schindler's List have really brought the horrors to film very well.. and there are still innumerable stories, documentaries, and books still coming out about the horrors the Nazis perpetrated in the 30s and early 40s. In fact, here is one from today at cnn.com too ..evil incarnate!!

The movie Downfall is based on two books Inside Hitler's Bunker by Joachim Fest and Until the Final Hour (BIS ZUR LETZTEN STUNDE) by Traudl Junge and Melissa Müller. Junge, who was Hitler's secretary and was with him in the bunker the last few days but made it out of the bunker alive after his death, died recently and in fact features in the movies in short clips both at the beginning and end of the film. (The 2002 documentary, BLIND SPOT, is an extended interview with Traudl, in which she expresses "plausible deniability" for the atrocities perpetuated by her employer.)

Also, if interested, click here for a good summary about the rise of Hitler in Germany... I think from a historical perspective, how he came to power and took sway over the entire nation is far more interesting than how he faced his end over his last few days...

March 2, 2006

Another rich snazzy Indian wedding..

The Vikram Chatwal - Priya Sachdev wedding was all the news in tabloid-ish socialite-following sections of all newspapers in India earlier this month! Now some international coverage too..

Blushing, hip bride - Wedding puts India onto the map of Global Cool, says IHT.

Who the f cares...

March 1, 2006

Ganguly-Chappell fracas continues

I have been a great fan of Chappell and his strategies and policies so far (and not so much a fan of Ganguly, who has not taken the graceful way out despite failing form and has instead become a divisive force within the Indian side)... but...why oh why would Chappell flare the flames of their fracas again with an interview like this..and that too now!

Captaincy was important to Sourav’s finances: Greg

Maybe this interview was given before the team for the first test for the England series was announced (and Ganguly left out). In any case, I would expect stuff like this to come out from Chappell at some later date when he leaves the Indian coaching job... (Will truly be interesting and controversial, to say the least, if/when some day Wright, Dravid, Tendulkar, or even Ganguly writes a book on their perspectives from their coaching/playing days over the last decade ..I'd be especially interesting to hear what Dravid has to say about what has transpired over the last year!)..but it is highly irresponsible for Chappell to come out with statements about captaincy being important to Ganguly's finances etc! I am not sure it is even accurate for I think it is more an ego thing for a hard-fighting aggressive guy like Ganguly and not money. The very reasons we loved Ganguly and drove him to be the most successful Indian captain are the same reasons he has failed to recognize that the end is here and it is time for him to leave gracefully! I had imagined he would have to be dragged out yelling from the field and surely he has proved to do that and more....

Though admittedly, Chappell does honestly state the facts as he sees them and is consistent in his reasoning..'Certainly, there is no way I would have got the job here without his influence. But, we clashed because his needs as a struggling player and captain and those of the team were different.'

He goes on to say, recalling Ganguly approaching him for batting tips during India's tour of Australia in 2003, 'I helped him with his batting then. So maybe he thought I would be his mate and support him now. I am sure he thought he would be able to run me as he did John in the latter part of his time as coach.'

Also: Chappell once again confirmed that he did ask Ganguly to step down from captaincy but the advice was only aimed at helping him revive his career. 'In essence, I told Sourav that if he wanted to save his career he should consider giving up the captaincy. He was just hanging in there. Modest innings were draining him. He had no energy to give to the team, which was helping neither him nor us. It was in his own interest to give himself mind space to work on his batting so that it could be resurrected but he was not prepared to do that,' he added. The Aussie said he had no idea what captaincy meant for Ganguly and why he wanted to cling on to the post despite the fact that he was undergoing the worst phase of his career. 'What I didn’t realise at that stage was how utterly important to his life and finances being captain was.'

And this rings true for sure... 'I am thorough, a realist, a pragmatist and I’m honest'.

This picture says it all - a no-nonsense Clint Eastwood-esque lion-like personality!

Anyways, the last is not over as apparantly, Saurav Ganguly has brought this piece to the attention of the BCCI... 'My attention has been drawn to the article by Sourav and I will take it up with the Board tomorrow' —BCCI secretary Niranjan Shah to DNA on Wednesday.

Update: BCCI has officially warned Greg Chappel.

Not one more refugee death, by Emmy Pérez

And just like that, my #NPM2018 celebrations end with  a poem  today by Emmy Pérez. Not one more refugee death by Emmy Pérez A r...